This episode answers a listener’s question about how to know when the time is right to have a baby. Whether you are thinking about your first child or adding to your family, the decision can feel overwhelming. We explore the emotional side of this choice, what medical organizations recommend about pregnancy timing, birth spacing, and how lifestyle, age, fertility, finances, and family dynamics can all factor in. You will also hear why waiting for the “perfect” time may not be realistic and how to sort through the noise and trust your own timing.

Listen Now

This episode is made possible with support from our sponsors. I appreciate your support for the brands that help power this podcast.

Inito is the first at-home fertility monitor that tracks four key fertility hormones (estrogen, LH, PdG, and FSH) all on a single test strip. Inito is 96% as accurate as a blood test, without the cost, wait time, or hassle of going to a lab. The Inito Starter Pack is available for just $89 with the code PREGNANCYPODCAST.

Become a Pregnancy Podcast Premium member or log in to access all articles and episodes ad-free.

Article and Resources

Hi Vanessa,

I have been a longtime listener of the Pregnancy Podcast. Your episodes helped me feel so much more prepared during my first pregnancy.

My son just turned one, and lately my husband and I have been having a lot of conversations about when to try for baby number two. We go back and forth on timing. My husband really wants our kids to be close in age. Me too, but I feel like life is still a little chaotic. I had a challenging pregnancy, and I am not sure I am ready to get pregnant again just yet.

I am not currently using any birth control. Part of me just keeps hoping I will get pregnant so I do not have to make the decision or overthink the timing. I know that is probably not the most responsible mindset, but I feel stuck between wanting another baby and not knowing if now is the right time.

I would be curious to hear your thoughts on what factors are worth considering when deciding to get pregnant again.

Thank you for everything you do!

Sincerely,

Melanie

Melanie, thank you so much for your email. I always love hearing from listeners who come back to the podcast while planning for baby number two. It is wonderful that you and your husband are talking about growing your family. I know many listeners are either thinking about having their first baby or growing their family. Your question captures just how complex this decision can be. Figuring out the right time to have a baby, whether it’s your first or your third, can feel overwhelming. Let’s talk about some key factors to consider that may help you decide whether now is the right time for baby number two or if it makes sense to wait a little longer.

Reflecting on Your First Pregnancy

For anyone who’s had a previous pregnancy, that experience can shape how you feel about doing it again. If this would be your first baby, you might be navigating uncertainty simply because everything is new. Melanie, I am sorry to hear that your first pregnancy was challenging. I know many listeners can relate to that experience. It makes complete sense that it would give you some hesitation about going through it all again. While I do not know the details of your last pregnancy, every pregnancy is different. Some complications or symptoms may be more likely to return, but many do not. You are not automatically signing up for the same experience again.

One advantage of a second pregnancy is that there are fewer unknowns. You have already been through this once, and that can make a big difference. Many moms feel more relaxed and less anxious the second time around. Even if your first experience was far from ideal, your increased knowledge and confidence can help make your subsequent pregnancy smoother.

Medical Recommendations on Timing Pregnancy

It takes time for your body to recover after giving birth. That recovery time is an essential part of planning for another baby. If you are exclusively breastfeeding, it can act as a natural form of birth control for about six months. From an evolutionary standpoint, this is nature’s way of helping your body focus on caring for one baby before getting pregnant with another.

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommends that women should be advised to avoid interpregnancy intervals shorter than 6 months and should be counseled about the risks and benefits of repeat pregnancy sooner than 18 months. That spacing would mean your children are around 2 years and 4 months apart, at minimum. The World Health Organization takes it a step further and recommends waiting 24 months.

Why is this spacing important? Getting pregnant again within 18 months can increase the risk of certain complications. This includes preterm birth (before 37 weeks), low birth weight (under 5 pounds 8 ounces), or your baby being small for gestational age. These complications can raise the chances of a more extended hospital stay or health issues for your baby. That said, while the data shows a statistical increase in risks with shorter spacing, it is not a guarantee that complications will occur. Many families have children closer together and have healthy pregnancies and babies. These recommendations are just one factor to consider as you weigh what is best for your body, your family, and your timeline.

Lifestyle, Career, and Financial Factors

Many lifestyle considerations can play into the timing of a pregnancy. You mentioned that things feel a little chaotic right now with a toddler, and that is entirely understandable. Life with a one-year-old is busy, and adding another baby to the mix is a big decision. It is worth thinking about the support you currently have and what you expect to have going forward, whether that is from your partner, extended family, or outside help. Access to childcare can also be a significant factor in managing the demands of parenting two young children.

Career and finances are another piece of the puzzle. If you are fortunate enough to stay home with your children, that may make you more comfortable having another child sooner. In the event you are on a break from your career, you might consider whether it makes more sense to continue that break rather than return to work, only to take another leave later. If you are currently working, that may not be as relevant, but it could still factor into your planning. Financially, there is no question that children come with added expenses. While you do not need to have everything perfectly in place, it is helpful to assess whether your current situation feels stable and sustainable with a growing family. There will never be a perfect time when everything lines up. However, some seasons of life may feel more manageable than others.

Fertility, Age, and Your Timeline

Age also plays a role in fertility. As you get older, particularly beyond age 35, it can increase the risk for certain complications during pregnancy. Because of this, many people feel extra pressure to have children before turning 35. Technically, pregnancy at 35 or older is labeled as “advanced maternal age.” While this term is based on statistical data, it can often cause unnecessary anxiety. The reality is that most pregnancies in this age group are healthy and uncomplicated. There are also real advantages to becoming a parent in your mid-thirties or beyond. You may be more emotionally and financially stable, and more confident in your parenting choices. Your age is just one factor, and it should be considered alongside everything else going on in your life.

Sibling Spacing and Family Dynamics

Wanting to give your child a sibling is a beautiful intention. There are many benefits to growing up with a brother or sister. If you’re thinking about how a new baby might impact your family dynamic, whether that’s your first child or adding a sibling, spacing and timing are important things to consider. Some parents prefer children close in age, while others feel more comfortable with a larger gap. Neither is right nor wrong, and it depends on what works best for your family.

Having children close in age can be more demanding in the early years, when both kids require constant attention and care. The infant and toddler stages can feel especially intense when stacked back-to-back. That said, some parents find it easier to stay in the trenches and move through those early years in one continuous stretch. The upside of a smaller age gap is that your children may attend the same schools at the same time, share friends, and experience similar stages of life together. This can foster closeness and make scheduling easier down the road.

A wider age gap allows you to focus more attention on each child at different stages. Plus, your older child may be more independent or helpful when a new baby arrives. You may also feel more physically and emotionally ready after having more time between pregnancies. There are pros and cons to any age gap, and ultimately, the sibling relationship is shaped less by timing and more by your parenting, their personalities, and your family dynamic overall.

The “If It Happens, It Happens” Mindset

Melanie, it sounds like you are open to getting pregnant now, since you are not using any form of contraception. At the same time, it does not sound like you are actively trying to conceive. This mindset of “if it happens, it happens” is quite common. It makes sense that part of you feels like if you get pregnant, the decision is made for you, and you no longer have to wrestle with the timing. If you are genuinely comfortable with that possibility, this can be a valid and low-pressure approach.

Even with this approach, you can still take small, proactive steps now to prepare your body and increase your awareness. You should also continue to take a high-quality prenatal vitamin. This ensures you have all the key nutrients your body needs to support another pregnancy. Even if you are not ready to be intentional about trying to conceive, tracking your menstrual cycle can help you better understand your fertility. You might also consider testing your hormone levels to get a baseline. You could use Inito, which is an at-home fertility monitor that tracks hormone levels and ovulation. These insights can be invaluable if you decide to be more intentional in the future.

The Perfect Time

Melanie, it is entirely normal to feel torn between the desire to grow your family and the uncertainty of doing it all over again. For many couples, there is a lot of uncertainty about when to get pregnant. The truth is, there is no perfect time to have a baby, whether it is your first, second, or third. Even with the best intentions and plans, timing is not always something we can fully control. Some women get pregnant right away. For others, it takes longer, even if they had no issues the first time around. The perfect time often ends up being when it happens.

It is easy to get caught up in the idea that you need to have everything perfectly lined up, like your finances, your career, and your schedule. While those things are undoubtedly important, the reality is that many couples spend years waiting for the “right time” and sometimes miss the window altogether. If you feel like you need more time, take it. The most important takeaway is that there is no perfect time to have another baby.

Since I was a kid, I always imagined having two children exactly two years apart; that was my ideal. The first time around, I went with the “if it happens, it happens” mindset and ended up getting pregnant with my son almost immediately. When it came time to try for a second baby, I still vividly remember my midwife telling me, “There’s a big difference between having a 2-year-old and a newborn versus a 3-year-old and a newborn.” I remember feeling frustrated because I didn’t want to wait. And I didn’t. But I didn’t get pregnant right away. By the time I was expecting my second, my son was nearly three. And in hindsight, it was perfect. That timing gave me the space I didn’t know I needed, and now, I truly couldn’t imagine my family any other way.

No matter where you are on your journey, thinking about your first baby, your second, or beyond, I hope this helps you feel more confident in trusting your own timing. Whatever your timeline ends up being, it is perfect for your family.

Additional Resources:

Thank you to the brands that help power this podcast.

Track Your Fertility Hormones at Home with Inito

Inito is the first at-home fertility monitor that tracks four key fertility hormones (estrogen, LH, PdG, and FSH) all on a single test strip. In just ten minutes, you get accurate, personalized hormone data to help you understand your unique cycle and optimize your chances of conceiving. Inito is 96% as accurate as a blood test, without the cost, wait time, or hassle of going to a lab. If you are on a fertility journey, Inito provides you with clear insights into your unique hormone patterns, allowing you to stop guessing and start understanding your cycle more effectively. The Inito Starter Pack is available for just $89 with the code PREGNANCYPODCAST.